Dine-In Service
Casual dining experience focused on fresh, hot pizza served at your table. Perfect for families and small groups looking for authentic NY-style pizza.
- Table service available
- Family-friendly atmosphere
- Fresh pizza served hot
At a Glance
NY Pizza Express has established itself as Matthews' go-to destination for authentic New York-style pizza, earning recognition for its crispy, non-greasy crust and fresh toppings. Despite its modest storefront appearance, the restaurant has built a loyal customer base who consistently praise the quality and authenticity of the pizza, with many noting it's the closest they've found to genuine NY pizza in the Carolinas. The establishment focuses on takeout and delivery service, emphasizing food quality over ambiance.
- Crispy, non-greasy crust
- Fresh quality toppings
- Authentic NY taste
- Excellent value pricing
Why Customers Choose NY PIZZA EXPRESS
Based on 373 customer reviews
- Authentic New York-style pizza made by experienced pizza makers
- Crispy crust that stays non-greasy using traditional techniques
- Fresh toppings including hard-to-find green olives
- Fair pricing with generous portion sizes
- Quick turnaround for call-ahead orders
- Consistently high quality that keeps customers returning
Location & Local Context
Address: 4520 Potter Rd, Stallings, NC 28104, USA
Phone: (704) 821-2020
Hours: Friday 11:00 AM – 9:00 PM, Monday Closed, Sunday 1:00 – 8:00 PM, Tuesday 11:00 AM – 9:00 PM, Saturday 11:00 AM – 9:00 PM, Thursday 11:00 AM – 9:00 PM, Wednesday 11:00 AM – 9:00 PM
Parking: Free parking lot available on-site
Peak times: Friday-Saturday 6-8pm, Sunday 4-7pm
Nearby neighborhoods: Matthews, Mint Hill, Indian Trail
Nearby landmarks: Near Matthews Community Center, Close to Cato Corner Shopping, 5 minutes from downtown Matthews
Services & Offerings
Takeout Orders
Quick and convenient pickup service with call-ahead ordering recommended for faster service. Most popular option among regular customers.
- Call-ahead ordering preferred
- Quick pickup times
- Hot and ready when you arrive
Pizza Specialties
Traditional and specialty pizzas made with authentic NY-style techniques and fresh ingredients. Buffalo chicken pizza is a customer favorite.
- Classic cheese and pepperoni
- Buffalo chicken specialty
- Custom topping combinations available
Italian Menu Items
Beyond pizza, offering traditional Italian dishes that complement the authentic dining experience.
- Pasta dishes available
- Italian appetizers
- Traditional preparation methods
Customer Reviews
⭐ 4.7 out of 5
373 total reviews
Most Frequently Mentioned
- Authentic NY-style pizza (89 mentions)
- Crispy, perfect crust (76 mentions)
- Non-greasy texture (64 mentions)
- Fresh quality toppings (52 mentions)
Rating increased 0.2 stars in last 6 months. 28 new reviews this quarter.
★★★★★
“This is the best pizza I’ve had since moving to CLT by far. Prices are good. Won’t be going anywhere else!”
— Nathan Shelton★★★★★
“I’ve been searching for pizza baked like the pizza I grew up eating in Western NY my entire adult life. Then I found NY Pizza Express and it is absolutely the finest pizza I have had in decades of living in NC. They serve the best Italian food in the Carolinas hands down! Fantastic 🍕🍝, and atmosphere.”
— Jeffrey Baker★★★★★
“Excellent Pizza. Call in and pick it up. Don't miss out on this pizza that is cooked to perfection and not greasy. Plenty of toppings for the pizzas including green olives. Give New York Pizza Express a try for your next pizza order.”
— American Eitel★★★★★
“The place looks a little run down and could use some updates, but don’t let that fool you — the pizza is absolutely amazing! The crust is perfectly cooked, the sauce has great flavor, and the toppings taste fresh. You can tell they really know how to make a good pizza. It might not look fancy from the outside, but the food more than makes up for it. Definitely worth a visit if you’re after great pizza and don’t mind a spot that’s a little rough around the edges.”
— Rome OdarFrequently Asked Questions
We focus primarily on takeout and dine-in service. Call ahead to check current delivery options for your area.
We use traditional NY pizza-making techniques including hand-tossed dough, specific sauce recipes, and cooking methods that create our signature crispy yet chewy crust.
Call-ahead orders are typically ready in 15-20 minutes. Walk-in orders may take 20-30 minutes depending on volume.
Please call ahead to discuss dietary restrictions and current specialty options available.
Buffalo chicken pizza is extremely popular, along with our classic cheese and pepperoni made with fresh, quality ingredients.
Business Activity
Status: Open now
Peak hours: Weekend evenings 6-8pm
Wait times: 15-20 min call-ahead
Popular this month: Buffalo chicken, Supreme pizzas
Similar Businesses Nearby
Texas Roadhouse
⭐ 4.2 (4219) · 3.1 miles
10400 East Independence Boulevard, Matthews
Bonefish Grill
⭐ 4.5 (2102) · 3.0 miles
10430 East Independence Boulevard, Matthews
New Asia Market
⭐ 4.3 (1900) · 0.1 miles
4400 Potter Road, Stallings
Lucky Strike Matthews
⭐ 4.1 (1949) · 2.2 miles
11210 Brigman Road, Matthews
Starbucks Coffee Company
⭐ 4.1 (816) · 3.1 miles
2233 Matthews Township Parkway, Matthews
Carrabba's Italian Grill
⭐ 4.1 (2401) · 3.1 miles
10408 East Independence Boulevard, Matthews
People Also Search For
- NY pizza Matthews NC
- Authentic pizza Charlotte area
- Buffalo chicken pizza Matthews
- Italian restaurant Matthews NC
0/100
Online Visibility Score: Excellent
How easily local customers can find and choose this business online.
Reviews & Reputation35/35
Online Presence33/33
Business Completeness17/17
Engagement5/15
This business profile is managed with Buzza AI on Clover.
Powered by Buzza AI on Clover
NY PIZZA EXPRESS manages this profile with Buzza AI on Clover. Business owner? Manage your listing from your Clover Dashboard.